MBAGeeks Forum

General

12 hours ago

Reflections From an MBA PI Room

Body

How I answered, what I chose to say, and what I deliberately left unsaid

When I walked into the interview room, the first thing I noticed was that no one rushed into questioning me.
The panel took a few quiet moments to read my form. No eye contact, no expressions. Just scanning.
That immediately told me something important. This interview was not going to be about how confidently I spoke, but about whether my answers aligned with the person described on that sheet of paper.

Q1.Why MBA, and why now

I consciously slowed myself down here.
I knew this was not the moment for a dramatic answer or a childhood dream story.

I told them that over the last couple of years, especially while balancing work and preparation, I started noticing a pattern in myself. I was reliable when it came to execution and meeting short term goals, but whenever decisions required structured thinking, trade offs, or explaining my logic to seniors, I felt underprepared.
To make that real, I shared one instance where the outcome was good, but I could not clearly justify why my approach was the right one.

I ended by saying that, for me, an MBA was not a sudden switch or a badge to chase. It felt more like a deliberate step to build decision making, articulation, and perspective at a point where I was already aware of what I lacked.

Q2.We have candidates with much more work experience. Why should we select you

I was careful here. I did not try to pitch myself against them.

I said that experience definitely adds depth, but it also creates patterns that can be hard to question. I explained that my preparation phase had already forced me to confront gaps in discipline, in how I take feedback, and in how I think under pressure, and that this process had made me far more adaptable than I was earlier.

I told them that while I may have fewer years of experience, I come with clarity about what I need to learn and a genuine openness to being shaped, which I believe is critical in a rigorous academic environment like an MBA.

Q3.Your graduation performance is average. How do you explain that

I did not defend myself instinctively. I said that my early semesters reflected poor prioritization more than lack of ability. I treated academics casually at first, underestimated how consistency compounds, and only later understood the cost of that approach.
I pointed out how my performance improved once my approach changed, and more importantly, how that learning carried forward into how I prepared later in life.

I did not blame the college or the system.
I owned the outcome and focused on what changed.

Q4.What will you do if you do not convert any college this year

I said that I would not treat a non conversion as a personal failure, but as feedback on readiness. I explained that I would reassess only three things, clarity of goals, communication under pressure, and depth of understanding, and continue only if I could see tangible improvement in those areas.

I made it clear that repeating the process without growth would not make sense to me.

Q5.Tell us about a failure you experienced

I spoke about a situation where I misread a team member’s intent during a group task and pushed my own approach too strongly, assuming alignment instead of checking for it. I explained how the outcome suffered, but spent more time talking about how that experience changed the way I now listen, pause, and confirm understanding before asserting my view.

 

Create custom feed

Make private

Communities (Select a community to add to your custom feed).